July 23, 2009
Four Real People . . . and the Obscenity of
American Health Care
She is in her late 20s when she is struck by
a degenerative kidney disease which
inevitably causes a years-long decline in
her health, followed by the need for a
kidney transplant. A merciful employer adds
her to management’s health care plan – a
plan normally unavailable to her as a
waitress – and she receives her transplant.
Subsequent to her relocation and taking on a
new job, she is stricken by a rare form of
cancer affecting only transplant recipients,
resulting in hundreds of thousands of
dollars of needed care. She receives the
necessary treatment, but is subsequently
terminated from her job, resulting in the
loss of her insurance – leaving her with no
coverage in the event of a recurrence.
He is 80 years old. As a public sector
retiree, he has what has been called the
best insurance plan available in his state.
Nonetheless, following a bout with cancer,
brain surgery, and an array of lesser
problems, his plan no longer covers the
continuing care he requires. Disabled to the
point that simple tasks such as showering,
dressing and eating require assistance, he
is forced to pay hundreds of dollars per day
from his own pocket, depleting a lifetime of
savings and threatening his future physical
and financial security.
She is in her mid-40s. A series of
infections in conjunction with environmental
and genetic factors have done extensive
damage to her liver, with troubling and
noticeable effects. She is in need of
aggressive, immediate treatment in order to
arrest her disease’s progress and limit
damage. Nonetheless, she puts off going to
the doctor, aware that her employer has a
history of finding reasons to terminate
individuals whose health insurance claims
appreciate beyond what the employer deems to
be an acceptable level.
She is in her early 40s, plagued by a
succession of chronic diseases. She longs to
move on from the dead-end job she hates, but
she knows that she’d be lost without her
employer-provided health care coverage and
that she’d likely be denied coverage – or
employment – elsewhere. She lives in
perpetual fear of downsizing as her company
goes through yet another round of layoffs.
These are the sort of health care horror
stories reform advocates routinely employ in
an effort to drum up support for a health
care system overhaul. What makes these
particular stories unique is that they are
not just an assortment of disparate
anecdotes. They are four specific
individuals who all happen to be close
friends of this article’s author, each
dealing with their own private health care
hell at the same time, doing the best they
can to survive in spite of a system that
doesn’t give a damn about them once the
checks cease to clear.
All are hard-working, middle-class Americans
with jobs, homes and families who have
dedicated their energy and their lives to
pursuing the same American dreams as anyone
else. In each case, somewhere along the way,
fate dealt them a bad hand, and the
profit-centric corporate health care system
was there to kick them when they were down.
Unique in this context does not equate to
uncommon: Unfortunately, the stories – from
town to town, street to street, family to
family – are sickeningly the same. There are
few Americans alive who do not know at least
one individual or family facing
circumstances such as these. Their numbers
rise seemingly in direct proportion to the
profits of the hospital conglomerates and
insurance empires.
Jim DeMint, Michael Steele, the Republican
Party, the
we-made-$13-billion-in-profits-last-year
health insurance industry and a cabal of
self-serving and corrupt “blue dog”
Democrats will be the first to tell you that
the system is functioning just fine as it
stands, and that enormous personal expense,
a state of constant anxiety, the denial of
necessary treatment and the effective
enslavement of a sick individual to a given
employer are acceptable byproducts of its
operation. As America stands at the point
where the interests of people and the allure
of profit cross, the well-being of its
citizens and its moral health are entirely
dependent upon the direction it chooses. If
it opts for profit, it deserves to rot in
hell.
©
2009 North Star Writers Group. May not
be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This
is Column # DBL066.
Request permission to publish here.