May 21, 2009
Bipartisan Gutlessness Sustains the Hell
That is Guantanamo
Participating in American democracy, if it
can be called that, is something like
attending a play or movie. You are
immediately conscious of your role as a
spectator, rather than an active participant
in the proceedings. And you are immediately
forced to suspend your disbelief the moment
you begin to focus your attention upon the
scenario playing itself out on the stage
before you.
You know going in that a lot of what you are
about to witness will bear no resemblance
whatsoever to real life, and you know that
you are effectively powerless to affect the
flow or outcome of events, no matter how
insane they may be. You swallow hard and do
your best to make believe that there is
something – anything – that effectively
separates the good guys from the bad. All
too frequently, though, even this modest
hope is mercilessly dashed. So it is with
congressional Democrats’ refusal of funding
for the closure of the U.S. concentration
camp at Guantanamo Bay.
In a show of truly Republican paranoia,
cowardice and NIMBYism, congressional
Democratic leaders have voiced their concern
that the Guantanamo hostages might be
rehoused in mainland prisons, possibly in
their own states, and that their presence
within any given supermax facility might
somehow pose a threat to the safety and
security of the United States.
Seriously.
Backtrack a little bit: We now know for a
fact that the vast majority of those
incarcerated at Guantanamo had nothing
whatsoever to do with terrorism or other
nefarious deeds, having been fingered for
U.S. arrest by various and sundry
unscrupulous tribal leaders or local
government officials eager to snag some of
the $5,000-per-head reward money. We also
know for a fact that in their eight years
within the barbed-wire-ringed, thug-staffed
hell that is Guantanamo, not one of these
inmates has managed to mount even the most
feeble acts of resistance – even a hunger
strike was crushed by force.
But we are somehow expected to believe that
a U.S. prison system that has successfully
contained and constrained evildoers ranging
from John Hinckley to Charles Manson can’t
handle a few battered, tortured, decimated
human beings who have been effectively
ground beneath America’s bootheel for better
than eight years?
Ah. Gotcha. Close Guantanamo, and suddenly
an anonymous Afghan peasant will achieve
superhuman powers: His superior strength
will enable him to effortlessly blast his
way through the walls of Leavenworth, even
as guards’ bullets ricochet worthlessly off
of his tungsten-hard torso. His heat vision
will blast planes from the sky. Deadly waves
of gamma wave radiation emanating from his
fingertips will crispy-fry good citizens
across the continent as they sleep in their
beds. Through telekinesis, he will levitate
the Capitol building, only to bring it
crashing to Earth atop Newt Gingrich and Pat
Robertson. Oh, the horror.
We’ve trusted our prisons – and our justice
system – to successfully handle suspected
serial killers, presidential assassins,
mafia bosses, drug kingpins, sociopathic
mall shooters and every manner of miscreant
known to humankind, but suddenly they’ve met
a challenge too great to face – the brazen
gutlessness, deep-rooted racism and blind
unreason of the American electorate who,
confronted with the prospect of actually
affording Muslims the same rights to humane
treatment and due process that they treasure
for themselves, find themselves overcome by
quivering cowardice.
And in a rare show of bipartisanship, their
Democratic congressional representatives
join forces with their racist and xenophobic
Republican brethren to cosset them, uniting
the nation beneath common disgrace.
©
2009 North Star Writers Group. May not
be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This
is Column # DBL057.
Request permission to publish here.