Read Stephen's bio and previous columns
February 17, 2009
A-Rod & Michael Phelps:
The Sports Media Must Be on Drugs
recent weeks, there have been two major news stories involving
world-class athletes and drugs, and both have caused some truly bizarre
reactions. Alex Rodriguez took steroids, and Michael Phelps smoked
marijuana. Both did things they shouldn't have, and I'm not defending
either, but the reactions many have had to them have either been
disproportionate, bizarre or downright laughable.
Let's start with A-Rod. The New York Yankees slugger tested positive for
two separate steroids in 2003. The testing that year was done as part of
a "survey" of major leaguers, meant to be confidential and remain
sealed, but they were seized by the government as part of the Barry
Bonds/BALCO investigation, and Rodriguez's result was leaked to
In an interview with ESPN's Peter Gammons, Rodriguez admitted that he
had used the drugs between 2001 and 2003, while with the Texas Rangers,
but never did before or since.
This admission is a big deal for baseball because the rulers of the game
had hoped that Bonds's departure, and last year's release of the
Mitchell Report, would lead to the "book being closed" on steroids in
baseball, and that eventually a clean athlete, like, say, A-Rod, would
one day break Bonds's career home run record. Now, it appears clear that
the steroid issue will continue to haunt the game for years to come.
Rodriguez took steroids, and will have to live with the consequences.
Questions will always be raised about the legitimacy of his career, he
may miss out on the Hall of Fame and the nine years he has remaining on
his ironclad contract may be a living hell, as he deals with hostile New
York fans. (Lucky for Alex, he'll have $270 million in remaining salary
to soften the blow.)
But here's what didn't happen. Rodriguez didn't "take away the
innocence" of the game. It never had any to begin with. And he didn't
exactly ruin his own reputation either. As was pointed out on Slate by
Tim Marchman last week, Rodriguez was probably the most hated active
baseball player before last Saturday, and he still is today. Whether
it's his bizarre demeanor, his well-publicized alleged affairs with
strippers and Madonna, his serial post-season failures or, (worst of
all) "not being a true Yankee," A-Rod has never been particularly well
Not to mention, it doesn't appear that the general public cares about
steroids nearly as much as Congress or most sports columnists do. For
all the talk that the steroid era has delegitimized the game, attendance
– and with it, revenue – have steadily risen in baseball throughout the
past decade, even as revelation after revelation about steroids has
trickled out every year.
No, Rodriguez shouldn't be banned for life – the rules of 2003 survey
testing would expressly forbid any suspension. No, Commissioner Bud
Selig shouldn't be fired as a result of this – the success of the game
in the last 15 years has outweighed the steroid issue in the eyes of
most people in the game. And no, the Yankees shouldn't, as New York
Daily News columnist Bill Madden suggested, release Rodriguez and
eat the remaining $270 million in his contract. Sure, they'd be "making
a statement," but it would still be insane.
Then there's Phelps. The all-world Olympic champion was snapped smoking
pot from a bong at a college party, and when someone else at the party
snapped a picture of the swimmer, the picture made its way around the
Sure, in doing so, Phelps disappointed fans who are vehemently
anti-drug. He was suspended for a few months of non-crucial competition,
and he'll have to do without a couple of his sponsors (though if
Kellogg's didn't realize how many stoners are frequent consumers of its
products, they probably do now.) But by the tone of some of the media
coverage and police response, you'd think Phelps had participated in a
He's not an addict. He doesn't need rehab. He didn't sell drugs to kids.
He's a 23-year-old guy who took a couple of hits at a party. Sure, he
was stupid to do so with unfamiliar people and in cell phone/camera
range. But of all the terrible things that athletes have done in the
last five years – domestic violence incidents, ridiculous amounts of
uncared-for illegitimate children, dogfighting, etc. – this doesn't rank
in the top 1,000.
Even worse was the insane police response, which led to a major
investigation, two search warrants and eight arrests. For a bunch of
college kids smoking pot? Really? Phelps's drunk-driving arrest, four
years ago, was much more worthy of outrage.
I'm not a drug user, I don't generally defend drug use and I'm not a
proponent of drug decriminalization. But I do consider it both unfair
and a huge misuse of law enforcement resources to arrest or throw people
in jail, or even investigate them, for taking a few tokes at a party.
In an ideal world, slugging ballplayers wouldn't take steroids, and
superstar Olympic swimmers wouldn't smoke pot. But in real life, our
athletic heroes disappoint us at times. Let's have some perspective in
analyzing these things, and not act like the offenders are the worst
people on Earth.
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.