Read Stephen's bio and previous columns
September 8, 2008
Final Notes on the
Sarah Palin Convention
John McCain’s acceptance speech Thursday night, which closed the
Republican National Convention, can almost be considered the exact
opposite of that of his running mate, Sarah Palin, the night before.
Where Palin gave a well-delivered speech, albeit one full of red meat
and cheap shots, McCain's speech was the reverse – it was respectful and
classy, but not delivered very skillfully.
The McCain who spoke Thursday was the John McCain of 2000-2004, the
post-partisan, reforming, reach-across-the-aisle,
not-afraid-to-distance-himself-from-George-Bush John McCain. It wasn’t
the John McCain we’ve seen on the trail for the past 18 months or the
one whom the party spent the week praising. Nevertheless, it was great
to see him again.
Sure, he tripped over his words a few times, had trouble with the
teleprompter and – again! – found himself in front of an ugly green
background. And even in the speech’s very stirring final seconds, McCain
tried to talk over the applause, which only had the effect of making him
The speech had some very affecting passages, especially in which the
candidate discussed his military service and the section when he vowed,
“I will draw on my experience, all the tools at our disposal, to build
the foundation for a stable enduring peace.” Or when he called out his
own party, something that doesn’t often happen in acceptance speeches at
he actually governed the way he came across in the speech, I'm convinced
McCain could be an excellent president. But I have no confidence
whatsoever that he will.
(An aside: What were three words long-associated with McCain that were
barely spoken at all at the convention? “Campaign finance reform.” Why
not? Probably some combination of the idea’s general unpopularity in the
GOP and the fact that McCain/Feingold hasn’t exactly worked out as
But regardless, this will never be remembered as John McCain’s
convention, but rather as Sarah Palin’s. Not only did the
vice-presidential nominee outshine her ticket mate, but none of the
other speeches or events were memorable in any way whatsoever. RNC ’08
will be looked back on first and foremost for Palin, with the
hurricane-caused delay and the “drill baby drill” chants likely taking
the second and third spots.
just over a week as the nominee, Palin has managed to galvanize the
conservative base in a way that not only McCain never did, but every
single Republican who ran in the primaries failed to do. If Barack Obama
wins in the fall, expect Palin to enter the 2012 cycle as the heavy
favorite on the Republican side – that is, assuming McCain’s loss isn’t
seen as her fault.
Indeed, the convention was full of moments of irony. Such as an angry
denunciation of “eastern elites,” delivered by a billionaire former
Massachusetts governor with two degrees from Harvard. Or a defense of
small-town values from a former New York City mayor. Or a shot at
Hollywood celebrities, at a convention in which Fred Thompson had a
prominent speaking slot. Or, strangest of all, a full-throated
bash-the-media strategy, used in support of a nominee with more of a
reputation for media popularity than any Republican politician in the
last 25 years.
The convention also included a very problematic "9/11 tribute" video
that looked more like the trailer for a disaster movie than any sort of
sincere tribute, and brought back the memories of the worst of what
journalist Chris Suellentrop, during the 2004 convention, called “the
GOP convention's nostalgia for tragedy.”
Meanwhile President Bush, not even in the house, saw fit to denounce the
“angry left” and predict – correctly, I guess – that McCain will have an
easier time with them than he did in the Hanoi Hilton.
During the convention, tribute videos were shown for the following
people: John McCain, Sarah Palin, Cindy McCain, Ronald Reagan, George
H.W. Bush, Medal of Honor winner Michael Mansoor and the 9/11 victims,
and that was just in primetime. Where was Dubya’s tribute? Did they try
to assemble one and just give up? .
And so, with the conventions ending after Labor Day for the first time
ever, we enter a 60-day sprint toward Election Day, with debates still
to come. The campaign has seen a thousand surprises already, with many
more likely to come.
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.