Paul
Ibrahim
Read Paul's bio and previous columns
July 20, 2009
Where Will We Go When
America Becomes Like Everywhere Else?
I
immigrated to America because it was supposed to be special. And it is.
Few nations have sincerely grown on the basis that God grants every
human being freedom and basic rights, and that as a matter of
convenience, the people will delegate only some of their powers to
achieve legitimately communal functions such as building roads,
enforcing contracts, resisting crime and fighting off foreign threats.
As
true and obvious as such a principle should be, it is sadly rare and
unique in the modern world. It is therefore no surprise that America’s
distinctive non-interference with God-given rights has attracted many
millions of immigrants from around the world, and that its capitalist
system has allowed it to become the most prosperous and powerful country
in the world.
Yet what is astounding is that, instead of continuing on the track that
has made America flourish to an unprecedented extent, the people have
been electing governments that rewrite contracts instead of enforcing
them, that tax the people to a degree beyond the wildest imagination of
the founding fathers, and that design enormous social experiments as
instruments that can be used to infringe on individual rights and
freedoms. In other words, through their politicians, Americans are
trying to make America like every other country in the world.
Does it not strike them that America is a nation of immigrants precisely
because just about every other country has been getting it wrong in just
about every era? And if America becomes like those countries, where are
we, immigrants and descendents of immigrants who escaped those other
countries, supposed to go next?
The fact is that big government of every flavor is available just about
everywhere else in the world for Americans who so embrace it. The
socialists can collectively enjoy mediocrity in Europe, and the
theocrats can have a blast in the Middle East. The communists can reap
the fruits of their ideology in North Korea, and the monarchists still
have reliable options around the globe.
But where would the rest of us, who actually wish to retain the freedoms
given to us by God, and who are willing to work hard in exchange for
rewards without government interference, end up if America went the way
of the rest of the world? There is nowhere else.
Now America has had the blessing of being divided into relatively
self-governing states, a rare luxury that has allowed Americans to vote
with their feet by abandoning weary states with big, intrusive
governments, and embracing the prosperous states most loyal to small
government ideals. This movement has been an incredible source of checks
and balances among the states.
Researchers have found that between 1998 and 2007, more than 1,100
people moved from the nine highest income-tax states (the bluest of
states) mostly to the nine tax-haven states every single day.
This movement is consistent with the fact that the recipient group of
states created 89 percent more jobs and 32 percent faster personal
income growth during that period. Indeed, those states that have the
highest taxes now also face the biggest budget gaps due to the exodus of
their tax base (see California, New York, etc.).
Assuming that ACORN does not “help out” too much with the 2010 census,
Americans’ embrace of small-government states will be reflected by the
reapportionment of congressional seats. At this point, Georgia, Nevada,
South Carolina, and Utah are expected to gain one seat, Florida one or
two seats, Arizona two seats, and Texas, with its pro-growth policies
and rejection of nanny statism, four seats. That makes for five solidly
red states and two swing states.
On
the other hand, Illinois, Iowa, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan,
Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania are each
expected to lose one seat, and Ohio two. All of these were blue states
in 2008, with the exception of Missouri (which went red by roughly 0.001
percent of the vote), and Louisiana, which has endured a serious loss of
population due to Hurricane Katrina.
Those who move include people in all economic brackets – the “rich” take
their money and their job creation with them, and those they employ
follow.
But when the federal government attempts to erase all differences
between the states through massive federal taxes and spending,
Americans’ ability to choose among 50 laboratories becomes decreasingly
feasible. What’s the point of moving between states if you will face the
same exact taxes and policies in each?
And this is what the federal government is doing. It is eliminating our
choices within the U.S. by giving us one giant central government that
we cannot escape. We’ve already established that foreign countries are
out of the question. So when America descends to their level, where will
we go?
Texas Governor Rick Perry has already hinted at secession, and the
libertarian movement, through the Free State Project, is already
coalescing in New Hampshire to give our founders’ vision one last stand.
One can only hope that it won’t get to that– but it’s not looking so
bright.
© 2009 North Star
Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This is Column # PI174.
Request
permission to publish here.
|