Read Herman's bio and previous columns
October 6, 2008
Taxpayers Robbed Again,
and It Won’t Be the Last Time (Watch Social Security)
There is an old saying that if you like sausage, you may not want to see
how it is made or what’s in it. That’s true of the national financial
crisis “bailout” bill passed by Congress last week.
is legislative sausage at its best.
The bill contained some important tax extensions such as relief from the
unfair Alternative Minimum Tax, but it also contained billions of
dollars in opportunistic pet pork projects – “earmarks”. What it did not
contain was transparency so taxpayers could easily understand what was
in it. In fact, the last time we had a transparent pork-free bill passed
in Congress was when the Constitution was signed in 1787.
Some people are still so angry about the crisis and how we got here that
they still cannot accept the fact that to do nothing was not an
option. Yes I am still angry, but I have accepted the painful
reality of a $700 billion economic medication.
The bill will not be an instant stimulus for national economic growth.
The best outcome is that it will loosen the flow of credit, and mitigate
the rapid economic decline that we have seen within just the last few
weeks. Hopefully, the taxpayers will not have to swallow much of the
$700 billion, if any.
But I do not accept the necessity of adding billions of dollars in
“sweeteners” to the legislation to persuade enough lawmakers to vote for
it in order to get it passed. Members of Congress will tell you that’s
reality. I say that’s bull feathers.
The taxpayers were robbed again.
There was another alternative plan that did not have a $700 billion
price tag and no sweeteners, but House Speaker Nancy Pelosi would not
allow it to even be introduced, debated or discussed. The alternative
plan was based on unleashing cash stuck in other countries because of
income tax rules, and cash stuck in investment capital accounts because
of capital gains taxes.
The alternative plan was developed by the Republican Study Committee in
the House of Representatives (www.house.gov/hensarling/rsc).
Obviously, Speaker Pelosi’s problem with the alternative was that it was
a Republican proposal. Surprise, surprise!
business, decisions are made based on the lowest cost and most effective
alternative solution to a problem. It appears to be just the opposite in
a Democratic-controlled Congress, which prefers highest cost and least
this is Speaker Pelosi’s definition of “A New Direction” as promised
during the 2006 election year, then I shudder to think of what Nancy
Pelosi and Harry Reid will attempt to steal from us if Barack Obama gets
The taxpayers have been robbed before.
were robbed when Congress voted back in the 1980s to allow Social
Security taxes to be used for purposes other than Social Security
benefits. They routinely substitute the money for “IOUs” and call it a
“Trust Fund” account. The only thing we can trust is that there are no
plans to ever put that money back into Social Security.
were robbed again when the Senate voted down a resolution to disallow
this practice a couple of years ago by an 85 to 15 margin. Most people
never even heard of this proposal because there was no visible and
immediate Main Street impact, and the mainstream media never gets
excited about a fiscally responsible idea.
Every time a bill is passed in Congress with “earmarks”, or money is
redirected for purposes other than originally intended, taxpayers are
being robbed of their hard-earned money and their freedom to say no.
Sadly, most of our elected representatives will not say no for us.
less than 10 years the Social Security system will have become a
financial train wreck. It will be another crisis and we already know
it is coming.
What we don’t know is how we will be robbed the next time.
© 2008 North Star
Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column # HC131.
permission to publish here.