Read Eric's bio and previous columns
January 12, 2009
Become Plan B to Fight Global Warming?
A few years ago, if you’d asked a climate scientist
whether to physically monkey with the atmosphere to mitigate global
warming, he’d probably have looked at you as if you were a lunatic. The
suggestions weren’t entirely science fiction. For as long as the climate
debate has raged, there have been suggestions that we simply could pump
stuff into the atmosphere to reflect more of the sun’s radiation. It’s
just that no one took it very seriously.
It appears that the idea is beginning to gain a little
traction, but not for reasons of optimism. The Independent of London
surveyed climate scientists and remarkably found a handful who say that
a Plan B, geo-engineering, is something we need to have in place.
According to the Independent’s story, it’s not that they like it,
but that there is a sense of gloom falling on the scientific community
that the world not will react quickly enough and strongly enough to curb
greenhouse gas emissions.
Part of that you can probably blame on the Chinese, who
appear ambivalent about their growing greenhouse gas emissions. The good
news is that, in 2008, China’s greenhouse gas emissions actually fell.
The bad news is that the reason for that is the lousy American economy.
Up until recently, China had sung the same song as George
W. Bush’s Administration – it would take no action without the other
major economies on board. Their counter-argument to their growing
emissions was that they still had a smaller per capita footprint than
the industrialized West. It was the ultimate game of chicken, with the
United States, India and China glaring each other down, waiting for
someone else to make the fatal mistake of taking global warming too
Barack Obama goes to Washington with climate and energy as
one of his top priorities, and has made appointments signaling that he
plans to do something about them. This came coincidentally at about the
same time that China showed signs it was willing to blink.
That all changed late last week when China announced that
it planned to increase its coal production by 30 percent by 2015 to meet
its energy needs. In doing so, the Chinese stressed their familiar “per
There are signs that the Chinese know that this isn’t a
real argument, that the real issue is tons of carbon dioxide released
into the atmosphere. Plans for new coal-fired coal plants include space
for technology to scrub smokestack emissions of carbon dioxide, and most
people believe that the Obama presidency will have a ripe opportunity to
craft important international agreements that include China.
But ramping up coal production 30 percent by 2015 would
render much of that meaningless. The Chinese can plan space for clean
coal technology, but none of what is currently available has been widely
Above all, there are questions of how to lock the released
carbon back up underground. Currently, there is only one major carbon
sequestration operation in the world, up in Norway, where carbon dioxide
is pumped down into the seabed. Every other technology is either
theoretical or not tested in a way that suggests that it is ready for
This march sideways, which is really what it is, has
started to leave the climate science community edgy. Last year, NASA
climate scientist James Hansen said that drastic cuts in greenhouse gas
emissions were needed in a year.
Since those don’t appear to be coming, what is left are
perhaps some of the wilder ideas about how to mitigate global warming –
geo-engineering. A few years ago, these ideas – such as pumping
particulate matter into the air to reflect more sun – were laughed off
the stage. These days, absent something not straight out of a science
fiction novel, what was once insane may become Plan B.
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.