December 7, 2005
Denying the Obvious: Our Defeats, Our
Making
What a
long way we've come from "Mission
Accomplished" aboard the flight deck of the
USS Abraham Lincoln.
Three
years into George Bush's Iraq folly, the
rabid bravado that marked the first phase of
U.S. war policy has been eclipsed by a new
strategy at least partly grounded in
realpolitik: Universal denial. As might
be expected from Bush's administration, a
complex problem is met with a simple
solution, in execution if not effectiveness.
As the ugly realities of this senseless
exercise in neocolonialism begin to become
visible to both the American public and the
world at large in the form of videos of
children's corpses incinerated with white
phosphorous in Falluja and U.S.
"contractors" randomly raking civilian Iraqi
vehicles with bullets to the strains of
Elvis, it becomes clear that the "isolated
incidents" of murder, torture and atrocity
are far from rare exceptions in terms of
American conduct.
And what
is the official response? Deny it. Whatever
the evidence, deny it. Deny that prisoner
abuse at Abu Ghraib amounted to anything
more that an isolated incident perpetrated
by �rogue� guards. Deny that white
phosphorous was used for anything more than
illumination in Fallujah, despite the
countless photos of burned bodies. When
soldiers post "trophy photos" of people
being tortured and bodies being desecrated
to blogs and websites, mumble something
about the strain of war and quickly move on.
When video surfaces of contractors randomly
strafing civilian vehicles, first deny that
it exists, then suggest the possibility of
an investigation, then change the subject.
In the
eyes of much of the world, there is nothing
to investigate. The evidence is in; the
bodies of the mutilated dead, the testimony
of the tortured, the photos of charred and
bullet-riddled cars at checkpoints with the
corpses of children still inside, the memos
urging the bombing of civilian media outlets
- all are available to see. Even the U.S.
Iraqi puppet prime minister, Iyad Allawi, is
decrying conditions in Iraq that are worse
than they were under Saddam Hussein -
Hussein, the man currently on trial in a
kangaroo court for crimes against humanity.
This is
the point at which a thoughtful nation might
ask itself what it had become. Fortunately
for Bush, the United States is far from a
thoughtful nation; a wider world exists only
as an abstraction to be bunted about like a
baseball on the low-rent pundit TV circuit,
with no genuine conclusions drawn and no
judgments made as to our rightful
role in it. That American might makes right
is taken as a given; even if the tallies of
dead and tortured we're racking up are neck
in neck with those of Saddam, there simply
must be extenuating circumstances
working in our favor. Mustn't there? These
aren't atrocities; these are just
unfortunate incidents. Deny it.
It
doesn't work that way elsewhere. To much of
the world, our role in Iraq seems simply to
kill people. Who, where, when, or how
doesn't matter: "Kill 'em all and let God
sort them out," the cynical USMC T-shirt
motto, is the message that is communicated
to Somalia, to the West Bank, to South
America. The second tacit message: If the
Yankees will do it there, they'd just
as soon do it here. So Venezuela
stocks up on Kalazhnikovs; North Korea races
to perfect its atomic bombs; and outside the
ranks of a small in-club of
favored-trading-status nations, the smaller
and weaker countries of the world gird
themselves against being trod upon by a
blind, stumbling, brutal giant.
The
triumphalism of the flight deck days might
be behind us, but that is scarcely likely to
be a source of much comfort in Caracas or
Tehran. Deprived of the victory it craved,
America is sure to be foundering around for
something else: Someone to blame. And with
each murmured bit of nonsense issuing from
Washington about Iranian supply lines to
Iraqi insurgents, or streams of terrorists
pouring over the border towards Baghdad, the
choosing of the next scapegoat, and thus the
next recipient of American wrath, seems to
draw closer.
Such is
the way of the stumbling giant. Blind to its
own imperfections, deathly afraid of being
called to account for its own conduct, and
most of all horrified at the idea that it
could ever be just plain wrong, a Bush-led
America will continue to run from
self-awareness - and thus headlong into the
next disaster, waiting for us just around
the corner. All of this rather than
recognizing that our defeats, whether on the
battlefield or in the court of global
opinion, are of our making and our choosing.
©
2005 North Star Writers Group. May not
be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This
is Column # DBL003.
Request permission to publish here.