January 22, 2007
Blame the Media for Reporting Truth
Donald Trump was asked last week about his still-simmering public feud
with Rosie O’Donnell, he responded incredulously that the two stars’
contretemps wasn’t his fault, or Rosie’s - in fact, it was “the media”
that was to blame.
does have a scintilla of a point, as the news media clearly gave
considerably more coverage to his battles with O’Donnell than they
probably should have. However, Trump is the one who went before the
cameras several times, called O’Donnell a “fat pig,” and talked about
how her girlfriend will soon leave her. This may not have been a
particularly media-savvy moment for Trump, but he must have known from
his years of scandals and other tabloid appearances, that reporters tend
to write down those sorts of quotes.
not just the Donald. Lately, when all else fails, all sorts of famous
people have been blaming “the media” when things go wrong for them. The
general manager of the St. Louis Cardinals, for instance, expressed
dismay at the “media coverage” of the team’s late-season collapse last
fall in which they lost 9 of 11 games. Apparently the complaining
helped, however, at least enough for the Cards to win the World Series
the following month.
perhaps most loathsome of all, the president and some of his supporters
- the relatively small group that hasn’t yet jumped ship over Iraq - are
starting to form the argument that we’re sure to hear a lot more of in
the coming months and years: That we would have won easily in Iraq, had
“the media” not prevented it by aiding and comforting the enemy.
other words, it’s the same argument that was made about Vietnam, one
just as false now as it was then.
modern-day right-wing politics requires quite a lot of false bogeymen,
and the big, bad media are one of the most prominent, ranking just ahead
of rampant child molesters, Mexican criminals, marriage-destroying gays,
and Koran-swearing Muslim congressmen.
argument now goes that the media has spent way too much time reporting
on explosions, terrorist attacks, sectarian violence, the lack of
security, the bungled execution of Saddam Hussein, and the lack of
enough troops or any discernable exit strategy. Why aren’t they writing
about all the new schools?
hear that negative news about the war is “hurting morale” among the
troops, as though our brave men and women - the ones dodging bullets and
IEDs every day without complaint - are somehow rendered completely
undone by something Katie Couric said. The media, of course, are also
never less than completely complimentary about the troops themselves.
media has simply done their jobs, and reported what they’ve seen. Some,
most notably John F. Burns and Dexter Filkins of the New York Times,
have been doing exemplary work from the start in Iraq. Numerous
journalists have been killed, wounded and abducted while covering the
conflict, many of them deliberately targeted by enemies who value a free
press considerably less than we do.
“reporting more good news,” consider this hypothetical: If a new school
was built in New York, and then a few hours later a bomb exploded five
miles away that killed 200 people, which event do you think would lead
the papers the next morning? If the New York dailies went with the
bombing, would they be “defeatists,” guilty of “coddling the enemy”?
who have a problem with that they’re reading in the papers should avoid
blaming the messenger and instead take note of the actual events. Blame
the Sunni insurgents, Shiite death squads, Muqtada al-Sadr, and everyone
else who wants to prevent the establishment of a free democracy in Iraq.
And after that, blame George W. Bush, Dick
Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld for going to war without a reasonable plan
for the aftermath, for refusing to change course until years after it
would have made any difference, and for baldly lying to the American
people about the progress of the war.
Boot, as arch an arch-neocon as you’re ever likely to find, showed
admirable honesty in a recent column in the Los Angeles Times,
when he attempted to sink the blame-the-media movement before it could
gain much steam. Newspaper correspondents, he wrote, have been a whole
lot more honest – and a whole lot more right - about the war in Iraq
ever since 2003 than the Bush Administration has.
It’s time for public figures – Donald Trump,
Donald Rumsfeld and all Donalds in between, to start taking
responsibility for their own actions, rather than passing the buck onto
those whose only crime is having the temerity to report on said actions.
feedback on this column,
© 2007 North Star Writers
Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
is Column # SS27.
Request permission to publish here.