January 22, 2007
Spanking a Crime? Disappointment Violates Your Rights?
It is
nothing new for conservatives to complain about the “nanny state.” We
constantly criticize government intervention into our business and
lives, largely because it usually results in an exacerbation of the
problem that’s supposed to be resolved by such intrusion. However, we
are only used to regulations on trade that are alleged to “help” our
businesses, and to bans on smoking and unhealthy food ingredients that
take the pressures of elementary thought off our shoulders.
But
now, government is digging deeper, into our families and all the way
into our childhoods. California will consider a Democratic proposal this
week that could make it the first state in the nation to make the
spanking of children who are three years old and younger a criminal
offense, and punishable by up to one year in jail at that. Even worse,
an alternative proposed punishment is a child-rearing class, most
probably given by, well, California government bureaucrats.
Of
course, the rationale behind such a bill is that it would control bad
parents who abuse their children. But, hold on a minute, there are
already laws that prohibit child abuse and that allow social workers to
remove the child from his home if need be. But if a smacking does not
cause an actual injury to the child, and has little effect other than to
teach the child to behave better in the future, why is there a need for
a no-spanking law? Once we move away from abuse and into the world of
spanking, we are far from the area of universal human rights, and far
from any justification for government intervention.
The
political forces in California responsible for this bill are reminiscent
of various elements of government across the country. They are no longer
satisfied with simply cutting your choices as to where to educate your
children. Now they want a say in how you raise them, too. They seek to
reverse an effective tradition that is thousands of years old, and one
that has served us well through this generation, simply because of
self-righteous concepts of personal enlightenment and clairvoyance.
This
latest move is, unfortunately, only part of a growing national problem
in the way authorities, from government to school teachers, view and
understand children. They are removing the emphasis from discipline and
individual responsibility, while replacing them with the solid
Franco-Californian feel-good principles of dependency and “self-esteem.”
One of the crucial settings of the battle
between the progressive Utopian view on the one hand, and basic human
instinct on the other, is none other than the school playground. Games
like tag, touch football and other chasing games are being banned from
many school playgrounds because they are too competitive. In some
places, such as Attleboro, Massachusetts, even dodgeball is being
forbidden because it is too “dangerous” and “exclusionary.” Where it is
not completely barred, the game is being modified so that children could
re-enter the game more regularly.
Basically, the message is: “It’s OK children, you don’t have to compete
your hearts out. In fact, you don’t really need to try at all. Just show
up, and we’ll take care of you, even if it means pulling all of your
friends down to your level!” We are not talking about children with
medical illnesses here. We are talking about depriving the average child
from experiencing loss, failure and pain in a way that would help him
grow up as a strong, competitive, disciplined and socially competent
adult.
By
taking away these normal childhood experiences, schools and the
government are raising a generation of Americans who will regard
disappointment as a violation of their rights, even if it is brought
about by themselves. They are raising a generation that does not
understand that success is a reward of hard work and good behavior, and
that, conversely, failure is a consequence of laziness and dependency.
Not
surprisingly, this course of government child-rearing goes hand-in-hand
with a certain attitude about society that rewards idleness and stifles
the spirit competition – and as such it shows no signs of stopping. It
is hence time to tell the interventionists that enough is enough. So
send your kid out to face the ups and downs of the playground, and for
heaven’s sake, smack your children when they misbehave on a train or at
the movies. If you don’t have the heart for it, I would be more than
happy to do it for you.
To offer
feedback on this column,
click here.
© 2007 North Star
Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This is Column # PI36.
Request permission to publish here.
|
|
|