Read Stephen's bio and previous columns
September 1, 2008
Obama Delivers a
Different Big Speech
Heading into the final night of last week’s Democratic National
Convention, perhaps the biggest criticism leveled at the Democrats was
that they hadn’t gotten tough enough on John McCain. While not quite
taking the hands-off, no-negativity approach of their 2004 convention,
the Dems hadn’t done enough to show McCain unfit for the presidency.
They hadn’t “gutted” McCain, hadn’t done enough to remind voters of the
worst offenses of Bush-Cheney, certainly not to the level to which the
Republicans will certainly have no qualms about attacking Obama next
week. Who would step up to the plate to draw the necessary contrasts,
and truly get tough against the opposition in a manner to which
Democrats have fallen short the last few cycles?
Barack Obama, to paraphrase one of his many slogans, was the attack dog
we’d been waiting for.
His acceptance speech, delivered outdoors in front of more than 70,000
at Denver’s Invesco Field, was an excellent one – but also significantly
different from every one of Obama’s “great speeches” of the past.
Obama’s famed 2004 convention address, his victory speeches after the
Iowa caucus and South Carolina primary, his Philadelphia “race speech”
and others, were marked by the candidate’s masterful, soaring rhetoric.
In Denver, this style was there, especially at the beginning and end.
But Obama’s speech was really three speeches. The first was the
familiar, beautiful rhetoric. The second was a “laundry list” of
specific policy proposals, reminiscent of convention and State of the
Union addresses during Bill Clinton’s presidency. And the third was a
very forceful and very authoritative denunciation of the Bush-Cheney
legacy, and of McCain’s intention to continue with key parts of it.
The third part was the most surprising. Not only did Obama go further in
his criticisms of both his opponent and the current president than I’d
ever seen him do before, but he was also much stronger in his
denunciations of the GOP than any other speaker all week. Sure, several
speakers, led by vice-presidential nominee Joseph Biden and 2004 nominee
John Kerry, devoted much of their remarks to attacking the Republicans.
But from Katrina to the mortgage crisis to the failure to catch Bin
Laden, Obama was out front on GOP failures more than anyone else in
The convention had gotten off to a somewhat sluggish start, with very
underwhelming speeches on the first two nights by Nancy Pelosi, Bob
Casey and (especially) keynoter Mark Warner, who did all but put the
live audience to sleep.
But the convention found its voice, first with Michelle Obama’s
remarkable address and Ted Kennedy’s surprise appearance on the first
night, through the effective and necessary speeches by both Clintons, a
rip-roaring talk on energy from Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer and
finally a set of remarks from Kerry – much more tough, authoritative and
defiant than anything he said on the trail in his entire 2004 run.
Sure, Biden’s vice-presidential acceptance speech was somewhat
lackluster, while Al Gore sped through one of his worst speeches ever on
Thursday night. But with Obama’s speech combined with those listed
above, this was undoubtedly the best collection of addresses at a
Democratic convention in recent memory.
For the convention’s first three days, anyway, the dual questions of the
state of the Obama-Clinton relationship and whether Hillary voters would
support Obama, all but dominated on-air discussion. Yes, I realize MSNBC
and Fox and the rest had lots of hours to fill, but the commentators
felt the need to devote roughly 80 percent of their airtime to the
subject. I felt especially sorry for anyone who dared show up to the
convention while wearing a Hillary button. Not because their candidate
lost, but because they likely had to dodge reporters and cameras running
toward them for the entire week.
The Democrats have shown throughout this election cycle that they have
learned the lessons of their failures of the recent past. They picked
the right candidate, appear to have smoothed over many of the hard
feelings of the primaries, and have now run a (mostly) strong
convention, culminating the spectacle of Obama’s stadium speech. Is the
election over? Of course not. But as we enter September, the Democrats
are in their best shape in years.
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.