Read Stephen's bio and previous columns
Baltimore’s Decline and the Triumph of HBO’s ‘The Wire’
weekend marks the beginning of the end of one of television's greatest
achievements, as HBO airs the first of 10 episodes that make up the
final season of "The Wire." Creator David Simon's multi-faceted
portrayal of an American city in decline is not only supremely
entertaining, but has more to say about America in the 21st Century than
perhaps any work of art of any medium this millennium.
The genius of Simon's creation cannot possibly be overstated. Combining
brilliantly written characters with gritty realism and sociological
precision, "The Wire" looks at its city, Baltimore, from every angle –
police, criminal organizations, politics, unions, schools and now
And, it does so with no particular ideological axe to grind. All those
filmmakers who made awful movies about the Iraq war this year would be
served by following "The Wire," which makes every point with masterful
subtlety, and comes to no political conclusions other than that all of
the above institutions are irretrievably broken. Simon may be as far to
the left as the directors of "Lions For Lambs" or "In the Valley of Elah,"
but "The Wire" is no brief for socialism, as socialism requires strong
started in 2002, and initially focused on a conventional-seeming battle
between police detectives and a specific West Baltimore drug gang, with
police using state-of-the-art wiretap equipment (hence the show’s name).
But with memorable characters, spry dialogue, and plot mechanics that
often came out of nowhere, “The Wire” soon established itself as not
just another “NYPD Blue.”
Created by Simon, a former Baltimore Sun crime reporter who wrote
the nonfiction book that was the source of the earlier cop show
"Homicide: Life on the Street," “The Wire,” early in its run, fell into
a pattern of reaction that would follow it for its entire run: Huge
critical acclaim, high praise from its group of fans, but thin overall
ratings and little mainstream appeal. There was even a two-year gap
between the third and fourth seasons, while HBO took its time deciding
whether to renew the show.
the show more popular? There are many reasons. The show’s narrative is
complicated and confusing, with dozens of characters in roles of varying
sizes and a continuity that can be very hard to follow. It’s about bleak
subjects, and in considering them it reaches bleak solutions. And, as
Simon himself has said in interviews, it can be hard to get white
audiences to fully embrace a show with a largely African-American cast.
(“The Wire,” though, is heavily popular in the black community,
especially among those who see a realism about their own lives rarely
glimpsed in TV.)
hardly know anyone who watches “The Wire,” with the exception of a
couple of friends who I’ve talked into doing so. But once viewers get
into it, usually by watching DVD sets of previous seasons, they often
become converts themselves, recommending the shows to others with
may be the most astonishing thing about “The Wire’s” appeal. To every
other television phenomenon this decade, from “Lost” to “Desperate
Housewives” to (especially) “The Sopranos,” a backlash has emerged by
the second season at the latest, that the show has “lost its mojo” and
that the writers must have lost control of it. In these cynical times
about pop culture, I’ve never seen anyone say anything like that about
“The Wire.” Reading blog discussions about the show, as I do every week,
just about the only thing I read is how great the episode was.
Following the first season’s look at drug enforcement, Season Two’s
focus on the city’s docks and the accompanying decline of the white
working class, Season Three’s targeted drug legalization scheme and
Season Four’s heartbreaking depiction of city schools, Season Five goes
somewhere new – the newspaper. Simon uses his experience at the paper to
show the Baltimore Sun, also in decline, due to years of budget
cuts, as well as people in charge who don’t know what they’re doing.
you’re interested in following “The Wire,” the first four seasons are
available on DVD, and selected episodes are available for those with
access to HBO on Demand. And the new season, of course, is running for
the next 10 weeks on Sunday nights. The show is a depiction of the
condition of the American city unlike anything we’ve ever seen.
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.