Read Eric's bio and previous columns
April 14, 2008
Obama Tells the Truth About Blue-Collar Resentment
week, we got another twist in the long, unfunny joke that has become the
2008 presidential campaign. It wasn’t the unfunny punch line, but rather
just a poke at the uncomfortable open sore that is the joke’s topic.
There’s no point in rehashing Barack Obama’s description of bitterness
in working America, and if you don’t understand why it exists or how
long it’s been around, you should watch Michael Moore’s Roger and Me.
Yeah, Michael Moore. If there’s anyone who understands working class
resentment and anger toward the political class, it’s him. It’s also
worth pointing out that Moore’s hometown of Flint, Michigan, isn’t in
any better shape today than it was back in 1989.
followed, of course, were cries of Obama elitism from the John McCain
camp. Hillary Clinton, apparently campaigning someplace other than
Planet Earth, suggested that in small-town America she’d met nothing but
grit and optimism.
While McCain and Clinton both gave Blue Collar America the noble savage
treatment, a Pew Research Center study said that the middle class’s
outlook was gloomy, and reported its study reflected the worst
short-term assessment in the poll’s history. Similarly, the federal
government reported that consumer confidence had hit a record low. Loss
of confidence and belief that you’re headed in the wrong direction, of
course, are the keystones of gritty optimism.
know that campaigns will play games with each other, and use those few
times when a candidate is honest with people as a weapon. This is one of
the many things that have turned the presidential campaign into a long,
painful slog, and the results speak for themselves.
Clinton and McCain have acknowledged tough times for industrialized
America. McCain told Michigan voters in mid-January that auto
manufacturing jobs weren’t coming back, and Clinton tapped into
simmering anger over free trade to solidify her win in Ohio.
and globalized trade is the tip of this spear. There is reality and
there is perception, and while the reality is that globalization started
well before NAFTA, the perception is that the pact signaled the start of
the wholesale selling out of blue-collar America by the political elite.
Resentment against global trade burbles to the surface occasionally.
Last decade, it expressed itself as rioting during World Trade
Organization summits, the worst and most famous of which took place in
Seattle. Marching in opposition to free trade were, among others,
representatives of labor unions – you know, blue collar workers who felt
left behind by free trade.
they’d feel the same way a decade later, as their communities continue
to decline and jobs continue to disappear, is unquestionable. The notion
that – after two decades of neglect by the political class – those
workers would stand with sleeves rolled up and optimism in their eyes,
invites laughter. Calling someone who correctly identifies these
feelings of abandonment an elitist, especially by Clinton and McCain, is
Clinton, for most of the campaign, has traded off her experiences as
First Lady during the prosperity of her husband’s presidency. (There is
a case to be made that the prosperity during his presidency was a
combination of tech market manipulation and the good luck of stable and
cheap oil.) McCain built his economic conservative street cred on the
notion of free trade, for which he received top honors from the
pro-free-trade Cato Institute.
ultimate question isn’t whether Obama’s comments were accurate. People
are angry and feel abandoned by the nation’s political class. If they
weren’t, the campaigns wouldn’t be trying so hard to cast their
candidates as agents of change. The question is whether that anger and
resentment can be engaged in a way that diminishes it, or whether the
candidates will dodge the issue and focus on irrelevancies . . . which,
unless I’m missing something significant, was the point in the first
North Star Writers Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback
about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
This is Column #
Request permission to publish here.