EATS &
ENTERTAINMENT
Read previous Eats & Entertainment
columns
March 12, 2008
DVD Review:
Into the Wild
Could Have Been Great
By Stephen Silver
Sean Penn's Into the
Wild falls squarely into the "a meditation on . . ." genre, the sort
of movie that combines lots of beautiful rural vistas with
meaning-filled voiceovers and examination of The Meaning of It All.
The film is at its best
when examining its fascinating characters and taking advantage of
several excellent performances and beautiful cinematography. But it's at
its worst when it apes Terrence Malick with pretentious monologues and
multiple instances of over-directing.
Adapted from the
nonfiction book of the same name by Jon Krakauer, Into the Wild
is the true story of Christopher McCandless, a young man from a
privileged background who essentially walked away from civilization.
Wandering aimlessly through the American west for a couple of years,
McCandless ultimately died alone in an abandoned bus in Alaska. The
book, adapted by Penn, was constructed from McCandless' journals and
stories of those who met him on the road.
As it tells the story
of an American from a privileged background who moved alone to Alaska
and died there, Into the Wild draws inevitable comparisons to
Werner Herzog's Grizzly Man.
That 2005 documentary told the story of Timothy Treadwell, who spent
several years living with the bears in Alaska before one of them ate
him. McCandless isn't as much of an engaging, oddball protagonist as
Treadwell, but he's still a fascinating character who keeps just enough
concealed that his motives remain mysterious all the way to the end.
McCandless is
well-played by Emile Hirsch, who in Alpha Dog and now in this
film has transitioned well from child actor to adult leading man.
It's also great to see
Jena Malone, from Donnie Darko and Saved!, as McCandless's
sister, and William Hurt and Marcia Gay Harden as his vacuous parents.
But the truly great performance in the film is by Hal Holbrook. The
83-year-old actor, Oscar-nominated for the part, plays an old man who
McCandless meets near the end of the film. The old man has suffered a
lifetime of disappointment, and Holbrook conveys it in heartbreaking
fashion.
The film's biggest
Achilles heel is its over-reliance on pretentious-sounding voiceovers.
At times, Penn even illustrates this by handwriting McCandless's words
on the screen. This never works, and it's shocking that anyone thought
it would. There's also too much of certain directorial tricks,
especially flashing lights in one sequence near the end. Luckily, some
of this is mitigated by an outstanding series of solo songs contributed
by Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder.
Had it made a few more
choices differently, Into the Wild may well have been one of the
best movies of 2007. It is, however, the best film Sean Penn has
directed.
The DVD, while expertly
transferred, contains no extras whatsoever.
© 2008 North Star Writers
Group. May not be republished without permission.
Click here to talk to our writers and
editors about this column and others in our discussion forum.
To e-mail feedback about this column,
click here. If you enjoy this writer's
work, please contact your local newspapers editors and ask them to carry
it.
This is Column # EE011.
Request
permission to publish here. |